cinereal ae9994806c lib/services: fix reload/readiness bugs and add compliance coverage
Fixes several correctness bugs primarily around modular services' recent
reload/notification options (#535695) and adds compliance coverage to guard them.

Fixes:

- `lib/services/service.nix`:
  - the reload-conflict assertion had inverted polarity, so it fired on the
    default configuration
  - the `mkIf` guard on `process.reloadCommand` had a misplaced paren, applying
    `!= null` to the `mkIf` result rather than to the condition
  - `process.reloadSignal` derives `process.reloadCommand`, so the assertion
    could not check `reloadCommand != null` -- that fired on every signal-only
    service. The command is now derived at `mkDefault` priority and the
    assertion is gated on `options.process.reloadCommand.highestPrio`, firing
    only when the user also set `reloadCommand` explicitly.
  - change `notificationProtocol` to a sub-module type
- `nixos/modules/system/service/systemd/service.nix`:
  - `systemd.mainExecReload`'s default ran `escapeSystemdExecArgs` (a list
    escaper) on the `nullOr str` `process.reloadCommand`; this threw
    `expected a list but found a string` and would have mangled `$MAINPID`. It
    now uses `process.reloadCommand` verbatim.
  - the `Type` default read a non-existent
    `config.serviceManager.notificationProtocol` instead of
    `config.notificationProtocol`.

Tests:

Extend the modular-service compliance suite to guard the above:

- Portable (manager-agnostic) eval assertions: `reloadSignal` derives
  `reloadCommand`, the conflict assertion does not fire on signal-only services
  but does when both are set explicitly, and `notificationProtocol.systemd`/`.s6`
  default to `false`.
- systemd-specific eval assertions: `serviceConfig.Type` (simple/notify) and
  `serviceConfig.ExecReload` are asserted on the resolved host units. This
  directly guards the `mainExecReload` fix, which threw before it.
- Runtime reload compliance test: a nested reloadable sub-service is started and
  reloaded, asserting the service observed the reload (recorded a SIGHUP marker).
  `callReload` receives the service's name path (the list of names from the
  top-level service down to the target sub-service); each integration joins it
  per its own unit-naming convention (NixOS dash-joins to the systemd unit name,
  e.g. `reload-inner.service`). Keeping it a path list rather than a read-only
  submodule option keeps the suite manager-agnostic.
- `doc/build-helpers/testers.chapter.md`: document `callReload`.

Follow-up to #535695.

Signed-off-by: cinereal <cinereal@riseup.net>
Assisted-by: Claude:claude-opus-4-8
2026-07-20 11:01:04 +02:00
2026-06-09 21:48:16 +00:00

NixOS logo

Contributors badge Open Collective supporters

Nixpkgs is a collection of over 140,000 software packages that can be installed with the Nix package manager. It also implements NixOS, a purely-functional Linux distribution.

Manuals

  • NixOS Manual - how to install, configure, and maintain a purely-functional Linux distribution
  • Nixpkgs Manual - contributing to Nixpkgs and using programming-language-specific Nix expressions
  • Nix Package Manager Manual - how to write Nix expressions (programs), and how to use Nix command line tools

Community

Other Project Repositories

The sources of all official Nix-related projects are in the NixOS organization on GitHub. Here are some of the main ones:

Continuous Integration and Distribution

Nixpkgs and NixOS are built and tested by our continuous integration system, Hydra.

Artifacts successfully built with Hydra are published to cache at https://cache.nixos.org/. When successful build and test criteria are met, the Nixpkgs expressions are distributed via Nix channels.

Contributing

Nixpkgs is among the most active projects on GitHub. While thousands of open issues and pull requests might seem like a lot at first, it helps to consider it in the context of the scope of the project. Nixpkgs describes how to build tens of thousands of pieces of software and implements a Linux distribution. The GitHub Insights page gives a sense of the project activity.

Community contributions are always welcome through GitHub Issues and Pull Requests.

For more information about contributing to the project, please visit the contributing page.

Donations

The infrastructure for NixOS and related projects is maintained by a nonprofit organization, the NixOS Foundation. To ensure the continuity and expansion of the NixOS infrastructure, we are looking for donations to our organization.

You can donate to the NixOS Foundation through SEPA bank transfers or by using Open Collective:

License

Nixpkgs is licensed under the MIT License.

Note

MIT license does not apply to the packages built by Nixpkgs, merely to the files in this repository (the Nix expressions, build scripts, NixOS modules, etc.). It also might not apply to patches included in Nixpkgs, which may be derivative works of the packages to which they apply. The aforementioned artifacts are all covered by the licenses of the respective packages.

S
Description
No description provided
Readme
5 GiB
Languages
Nix 95%
Shell 2%
Python 1.8%
Rust 0.3%
JavaScript 0.2%
Other 0.4%